do-ip6: no ; config options server: trust-anchor: "nsec.example. IN DS 41524 8 2 D6B102667845D6CDDC05B44466426D9CCC189989BF67ADB23605EED0 BFE2A443" val-override-date: "20170401000000" ;stub-zone: ; name: "." stub-addr: 192.0.2.1 # ns. CONFIG_END SCENARIO_BEGIN Test validation of NSEC name error responses. ; ns. RANGE_BEGIN 0 100 ADDRESS 192.0.2.1 ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION . IN NS SECTION ANSWER . 3600 IN NS ns. SECTION ADDITIONAL ns. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.1 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns. IN A SECTION ANSWER ns. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.1 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns. IN AAAA SECTION AUTHORITY . 3600 IN SOA . . 0 0 0 0 0 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode subdomain ADJUST copy_id copy_query REPLY QR NOERROR SECTION QUESTION example. IN CNAME SECTION AUTHORITY example. 3600 IN NS ns.example. SECTION ADDITIONAL ns.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.2 ENTRY_END RANGE_END ; ns.example. RANGE_BEGIN 0 100 ADDRESS 192.0.2.2 ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION example. IN NS SECTION ANSWER example. 3600 IN NS ns.example. SECTION ADDITIONAL ns.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.2 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns.example. IN A SECTION ANSWER ns.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.2 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns.example. IN AAAA SECTION AUTHORITY example. 3600 IN SOA . . 0 0 0 0 0 ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode subdomain ADJUST copy_id copy_query REPLY QR NOERROR SECTION QUESTION nsec.example. IN CNAME SECTION AUTHORITY nsec.example. 3600 IN NS ns.nsec.example. SECTION ADDITIONAL ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.3 ENTRY_END RANGE_END ; ns.nsec.example. RANGE_BEGIN 0 100 ADDRESS 192.0.2.3 ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION nsec.example. IN NS SECTION ANSWER nsec.example. 3600 IN NS ns.nsec.example. nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG NS 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. KECif/B3ckfo5d9Qd/5dtIDt/8nIpTfTMxeJU3qw1U8jzQ/+nQ6qZAvr GH4MeGwY0M9kj2Jj3h2tdI+uhfLaGC7LStXIG0Q+PfalGdddDQwwd/p0 oOQ6bt0eilZN5OKF7Frzn4jmV1x7R/iieWp65xB7OByvguYoXOlzuoU1 ikaL43rm/whxn6iHf0K7NfaVqQwO26N/P3EBFFZMwuhHOB2+bVXKoE7r O4bC04tF7wG7CRUlc44xNs08L512RXRuFIrkHg932BFVlEYmPwbflE6+ zfpZafFzYutEHx7XZw2+gAklynmcAXltPCOiqThkDJzw2rpyUmiH0ztm lG76Tg== SECTION ADDITIONAL ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.3 ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG A 8 3 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. E6Cx+MIElwAbw4Hg48Ee4CC4pKSjPkW8fmcHVoTqNwMyRs4Jjyymf1tE mNdjYkoN0kxI8PEgbGxzuwlFLpGncQhuZ0dyTzCPvnYFPLIkDmdtyIcj 4MVZiJpdyc5yRTC+Aja1Ik9cQ25QsSGAg4z54Zv0o6uqodppCHILgBzm Q833AQFh6hOQE3BFM3c8h3PCsH6HJOOIlgqculfT5d0S1XPFGmtjVW4G gZNsNeBtLB/SkvYKzNS+Yw38J9VTtWMlgTUwkjVXzC+f83AgzXHM3neq QhRhf72VO/xP5sd33VXDVBtOqbFSDZHLpGLfaXJSrnzKX5H8nCMuIXbs kWK60w== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns.nsec.example. IN A SECTION ANSWER ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN A 192.0.2.3 ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG A 8 3 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. E6Cx+MIElwAbw4Hg48Ee4CC4pKSjPkW8fmcHVoTqNwMyRs4Jjyymf1tE mNdjYkoN0kxI8PEgbGxzuwlFLpGncQhuZ0dyTzCPvnYFPLIkDmdtyIcj 4MVZiJpdyc5yRTC+Aja1Ik9cQ25QsSGAg4z54Zv0o6uqodppCHILgBzm Q833AQFh6hOQE3BFM3c8h3PCsH6HJOOIlgqculfT5d0S1XPFGmtjVW4G gZNsNeBtLB/SkvYKzNS+Yw38J9VTtWMlgTUwkjVXzC+f83AgzXHM3neq QhRhf72VO/xP5sd33VXDVBtOqbFSDZHLpGLfaXJSrnzKX5H8nCMuIXbs kWK60w== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION ns.nsec.example. IN AAAA SECTION AUTHORITY nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN NSEC nsec.example. A RRSIG NSEC nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== ns.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG NSEC 8 3 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. iOfnQqIT9V87emJsd/Aym6JqU4H8bzjNq3cbWUmiohgdKr2pkqdt3RV1 r/LGbhSm+seWC/xWuBinEH2WAwXwQMUGrYi5htGazk9C97gkSvle/gXT NZweNC7SkrkBv1VXHG/PrinzFP/YWRn7zMn7fOj/uYWDaYAi0Fzh+Ctn fx2hsHIXC9LduIs+Uv9B58tr9tkF5JNYapoZO59Wtiz1GPaPnfUg9X2u 2T+J5rWpYHJkzKulW+yi0YpipfJY+9J9KWGr2PorChm/W1mc83MptyK2 Po+IbX/I0YStNv+nCLccBo94y/DGOLVnF0XpJZnR5ZDcb8ZmbZIP7uD3 GBFKMg== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qtype qname ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION nsec.example. IN DNSKEY SECTION ANSWER nsec.example. 3600 IN DNSKEY 257 3 8 AwEAAbgyvYQ2Vlff/inpv4NZLlIk2+l1sL0JoeOUlWHZ3eeWXZKxQJak QIXyGi8xsuANzu/YStLp31SfU/Fj4piUciqA+U74Lot1S/jcM7/1eczh 69YqGUAPZkreZ3z2DpWzBN4lgPR/w0OvTada3D42uV2bzuSK/nXMiMpZ vP1vZ1ykNRmbksTzA+HnrefRi2yuMSUqMHbtfbfFwqVTQ1ddVwSK7qIJ 02jo95YJUSZDPUUQlczIsFsa7Zxn6gQZl+iaRuDY6nLxxStYYlcqZhVA G5U8Dx4IznQ0FkEJp9RXtv5rmtClcQpudCl1gE0GC/W+TTUAa3hD597f onH+s/OfdCE= nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG DNSKEY 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. Z1kUmre0LJX76zuKEYhCN5bNNPvXONZK8LElwgNqEQW4kPApz8+vfLmb 4Xlz6D9ChG6J0Pp/JHdKn+S+Le4B5dUOPzuOksfkHTmRsh9oN2ccSEq3 eJK1VhWwRN69xs1LZgXzVJk7DnDnPVUyIbDpb5piBCJHQVwkrIa1Ykeh hexHJb7YZBmF1B6GqTl7K9QwIvfnpKH+iM83QngepAJqpJuHSEPNWCbQ S9rfuP1SObyZD4L/Z3hBFpaZL9N25ThH7znfTc60xNCitmNMFfq68X2/ JoSrVrFLNv9nlneYNkihorhzDMlzN/i/EhrtBkdaSiRlEODnY7zN4Eax m3JkFQ== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION local.nsec.example. IN A SECTION ANSWER local.nsec.example. 3600 IN A 10.6.6.6 local.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG A 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. H6auzgGxcWIcfhki7px+Iza4QRw5V47GXpPFDofXoORBdGtVYOhx+ILM pYA8ng4rzYCRFh/g9j8lIzU9y9WDfJyy8CMAJUsjiin/b9iJ0heQQU9r GmV1v+MvNxlcfMdJrec2O31RKBt7bK/FFesD4l3c3+XauwsOIsry+4t6 48uzUO48QVsbuw0PPDH82fPpSNgWyiAIEVwzz/tgrekk4eDwTVUkle4A 9ntjr5CFyKuoeDVTr0rZdJ90W6j4KYRUuk3x1V5w8eil7pNIN3arBzEv OXg4Du3AYskQ98a1VWz7MO/MX9u5WciXSbpDdI/2VtxMeKzkPotDds65 zLIsTA== SECTION AUTHORITY *.nsec.example. 3600 IN NSEC ns.nsec.example. A RRSIG NSEC *.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG NSEC 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. Hp/6sgDgYZuewpSkAugLRERgVAGgAIAN9vAqfuAGcqCxfQXLIXcXD8ji o4rjuSMmAaRw0AQ70pEWldc2Yqre+++/lnEJt5tpGrIhH2raJU9RS/Ix NaN40vwspRdN7tDNLH1T0oTDll76bVc/D4VFtnpGOlM3eIGjFVVdACvZ V0oVW8xp686xwB3uP2DqA0fxMjs4p9PC1FrnTAlGvTX0ThgZR6EmmWJH HCy4kpjfTFR93k/nuAendDVVZNkHL+EncojmUX+U0PRSZPXWBWXbb0kq h1OVaT4HpyWKet+PxKkTGaoNbXRk0BAKC/4Qg4A/+kRk+1OXG4dQMdsS zLnt/Q== ENTRY_END ; missing NSEC proof ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-nodata.local.nsec.example. IN CNAME SECTION ANSWER nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-nodata.local.nsec.example. IN RRSIG SECTION ANSWER missing-nsec-nodata.local.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG A 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. H6auzgGxcWIcfhki7px+Iza4QRw5V47GXpPFDofXoORBdGtVYOhx+ILM pYA8ng4rzYCRFh/g9j8lIzU9y9WDfJyy8CMAJUsjiin/b9iJ0heQQU9r GmV1v+MvNxlcfMdJrec2O31RKBt7bK/FFesD4l3c3+XauwsOIsry+4t6 48uzUO48QVsbuw0PPDH82fPpSNgWyiAIEVwzz/tgrekk4eDwTVUkle4A 9ntjr5CFyKuoeDVTr0rZdJ90W6j4KYRUuk3x1V5w8eil7pNIN3arBzEv OXg4Du3AYskQ98a1VWz7MO/MX9u5WciXSbpDdI/2VtxMeKzkPotDds65 zLIsTA== ENTRY_END ; synthesized A record was removed and replaced with SOA but no NSEC ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. IN A SECTION ANSWER nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. IN RRSIG SECTION ANSWER missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG A 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. H6auzgGxcWIcfhki7px+Iza4QRw5V47GXpPFDofXoORBdGtVYOhx+ILM pYA8ng4rzYCRFh/g9j8lIzU9y9WDfJyy8CMAJUsjiin/b9iJ0heQQU9r GmV1v+MvNxlcfMdJrec2O31RKBt7bK/FFesD4l3c3+XauwsOIsry+4t6 48uzUO48QVsbuw0PPDH82fPpSNgWyiAIEVwzz/tgrekk4eDwTVUkle4A 9ntjr5CFyKuoeDVTr0rZdJ90W6j4KYRUuk3x1V5w8eil7pNIN3arBzEv OXg4Du3AYskQ98a1VWz7MO/MX9u5WciXSbpDdI/2VtxMeKzkPotDds65 zLIsTA== ENTRY_END ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode subdomain ADJUST copy_id copy_query REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION local.nsec.example. IN NS SECTION AUTHORITY nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 *.nsec.example. 3600 IN NSEC ns.nsec.example. A RRSIG NSEC nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== *.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG NSEC 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. Hp/6sgDgYZuewpSkAugLRERgVAGgAIAN9vAqfuAGcqCxfQXLIXcXD8ji o4rjuSMmAaRw0AQ70pEWldc2Yqre+++/lnEJt5tpGrIhH2raJU9RS/Ix NaN40vwspRdN7tDNLH1T0oTDll76bVc/D4VFtnpGOlM3eIGjFVVdACvZ V0oVW8xp686xwB3uP2DqA0fxMjs4p9PC1FrnTAlGvTX0ThgZR6EmmWJH HCy4kpjfTFR93k/nuAendDVVZNkHL+EncojmUX+U0PRSZPXWBWXbb0kq h1OVaT4HpyWKet+PxKkTGaoNbXRk0BAKC/4Qg4A/+kRk+1OXG4dQMdsS zLnt/Q== ENTRY_END RANGE_END ; Extra entries for a validator that is not a recursive resolver. RANGE_BEGIN 0 100 ADDRESS 6.6.6.6 ; synthesized A record was removed and replaced with SOA but no NSEC ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH opcode qname qtype ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA NOERROR SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. IN A SECTION ANSWER nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== ENTRY_END ; end of 6.6.6.6 RANGE_END STEP 10 QUERY ENTRY_BEGIN REPLY RD DO SECTION QUESTION aaa.local.nsec.example. IN CNAME ENTRY_END ; recursion happens here, we expect NODATA with wildcard proof STEP 11 CHECK_ANSWER ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH all ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA AD NOERROR SECTION QUESTION aaa.local.nsec.example. IN CNAME SECTION AUTHORITY nsec.example. 3600 IN SOA ns.nsec.example. root.nsec.example. 6 60 60 120 3600 *.nsec.example. 3600 IN NSEC ns.nsec.example. A RRSIG NSEC nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG SOA 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. gZCIxxFWL04vgzuNbZYq3Ghb7OZsZCp1WCcByM602yEgf0IUk8KSqkol pTem3IXQELhFTzbddGFV3Cis5MxZq8XjNbSwXelbUkOkKE4EzDcpldtR yqGnp+ZdZhBrymZvS8dOhwOGllF6AobXx7iFHaY7wtC17XvODduxOBdV mQ/t2QDUnl+Io3s1KfDRf4e22WvtatlQNr9NW+PueeGtGhEdDeyR7VMA fxEqL6Lds7NWN7DPKfsCVgUNkwHzy9opQ64AyVyQAmwRohuon652jKiu MbvJ1vaLxJLeDBnnT3hbMrI/CIfmjqucSOgM9JNXXggIcfBxok5Ze2R5 SL35VA== *.nsec.example. 3600 IN RRSIG NSEC 8 2 3600 20170419140236 20170320140236 41524 nsec.example. Hp/6sgDgYZuewpSkAugLRERgVAGgAIAN9vAqfuAGcqCxfQXLIXcXD8ji o4rjuSMmAaRw0AQ70pEWldc2Yqre+++/lnEJt5tpGrIhH2raJU9RS/Ix NaN40vwspRdN7tDNLH1T0oTDll76bVc/D4VFtnpGOlM3eIGjFVVdACvZ V0oVW8xp686xwB3uP2DqA0fxMjs4p9PC1FrnTAlGvTX0ThgZR6EmmWJH HCy4kpjfTFR93k/nuAendDVVZNkHL+EncojmUX+U0PRSZPXWBWXbb0kq h1OVaT4HpyWKet+PxKkTGaoNbXRk0BAKC/4Qg4A/+kRk+1OXG4dQMdsS zLnt/Q== ENTRY_END ;; TODO: use INCLUDE when it's available. ;; Aggressive cache can answer STEP20 without asking, ;; from the record in previous answer, so it has been split-out for now. ; missing data in NOERROR answer synthtesized from wildcard must be detected STEP 30 QUERY ENTRY_BEGIN REPLY RD DO SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. IN A ENTRY_END STEP 31 CHECK_ANSWER ENTRY_BEGIN MATCH all ADJUST copy_id REPLY QR AA SERVFAIL SECTION QUESTION missing-nsec-masked-data.local.nsec.example. IN A ENTRY_END SCENARIO_END