/* Copyright (c) 2014, 2024, Oracle and/or its affiliates. This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License, version 2.0, as published by the Free Software Foundation. This program is designed to work with certain software (including but not limited to OpenSSL) that is licensed under separate terms, as designated in a particular file or component or in included license documentation. The authors of MySQL hereby grant you an additional permission to link the program and your derivative works with the separately licensed software that they have either included with the program or referenced in the documentation. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License, version 2.0, for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301 USA */ #ifndef RPL_REPLICA_COMMIT_ORDER_MANAGER #define RPL_REPLICA_COMMIT_ORDER_MANAGER #include #include #include #include "my_dbug.h" #include "my_inttypes.h" #include "mysql/components/services/bits/mysql_cond_bits.h" #include "mysql/components/services/bits/mysql_mutex_bits.h" #include "sql/changestreams/apply/commit_order_queue.h" // Commit_order_queue #include "sql/rpl_rli_pdb.h" // get_thd_worker class THD; class Commit_order_lock_graph; /** On a replica and only on a replica, this class is responsible for committing the applied transactions in the same order as was observed on the source. The key components of the commit order management are: - This class, that wraps the commit order management, allowing for API clients to schedule workers for committing, make workers wait for their turn to commit, finish up a scheduled worker task and allow for others to progress. - A commit order queue of type `cs::apply::Commit_order_queue` that holds the sequence by which worker threads should commit and the committing order state for each of the scheduled workers. - The MDL infra-structure which allows for: one worker to wait for another to finish when transactions need to be committed in order; detect deadlocks involving workers waiting on each other for their turn to commit and non-worker threads waiting on meta-data locks held by worker threads. The worker thread progress stages relevant to the commit order management are: - REGISTERED: the worker thread as been added to the commit order queue by the coordinator and is allowed to start applying the transaction. - FINISHED APPLYING: the worker thread just finished applying the transaction and checks if it needs to wait for a preceding worker to finish committing. - REQUESTED GRANT: the worker thread waits on the MDL graph for the preceding worker to finish committing. - WAITED: the worker thread finished waiting (either is the first in the commit order queue or has just been grantted permission to continue). - RELEASE NEXT: the worker thread removes itself from the commit order queue, checks if there is any worker waiting on the commit order and releases such worker iff is the preceding worker for the waiting worker. - FINISHED: the worker marks itself as available to take on another transaction to apply. The progress of the worker within the stages: +-------------------------+ | | v | [REGISTERED] | | | v | [FINISHED APPLYING] | | | Worker is | first in the queue? | / \ | yes / \ no | / v | \ [REQUESTED GRANT] | \ / | \ / | \ / | | | v | [WAITED] | | | v | [RELEASE NEXT] | | | v | [FINISHED] | | | +-------------------------+ Lock-free structures and atomic access to variables are used to manage the commit order queue and to keep the worker stage transitions. This means that there is no atomicity in regards to changes performed in the queue or in the MDL graph within a given stage. Hence, stages maybe skipped and sequentially scheduled worker threads may overlap in the same stage. In the context of the following tables, let W1 be a worker that is scheduled to commit before some other worker W2. The behavior of W2 (rows) towards W1 (columns) in regards to thread synchronization, based on the stage of each thread: +------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------+ | \ W1 | REGISTERED | FINISHED | REQUESTED | WAITED | RELEASE | FINISHED | | W2 \ | | APPLYING | GRANT | | NEXT | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REGISTERED | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | FIN. APPL. | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REQ. GRANT | WAIT | WAIT | WAIT | WAIT | WAIT | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | WAITED | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REL. NEXT | | | | | WAIT | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | FINISHED | | | | | | | +------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ The W2 wait when both worker threads are in the RELEASE NEXT stage happens in the case W2 never entered the REQUESTED GRANT stage. This case may happen if W1 being in RELEASE NEXT removes itself from the queue before W2 enters FINISHED APPLYING and then W2 reaches the RELEASE NEXT stage before W1 exits it: [W1] [W2] stage = RELEASE NEXT stage = REGISTERED | | v | queue.pop() v | stage = FINISHED_APPLYING | | v v next_worker.stage queue.front() == W2 == FINISHED_APPLYING | | | | v | stage = WAITED | | | v | stage = RELEASE NEXT | | v v next_worker.release() queue.pop() The commit order queue includes mechanisms that block the popping until the preceding worker finishes the releasing operation. This wait will only be active for the amount of time that takes for W1 to change the values of the MDL graph structures needed to release W2, which is a very small amount of cycles. The behavior of W1 (rows) towards W2 (columns)in regards to thread synchronization, based on the stage of each thread: +------------+-----------------------------------------------------------------+ | \ W2 | REGISTERED | FINISHED | REQUESTED | WAITED | RELEASE | FINISHED | | W1 \ | | APPLYING | GRANT | | NEXT | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REGISTERED | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | FIN. APPL. | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REQ. GRANT | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | WAITED | | | | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | REL. NEXT | | GRANT | GRANT | | | | +------------+------------+----------+-----------+--------+---------+----------+ | FINISHED | | | | | | | +------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ The W1 grant to W2 may happen when W2 is either in the FINISHED APPLYING or REQUESTED GRANT stages. W1 must also signal the grant when W2 is in FINISHED APPLYING because W1 has no way to determine if W2 has already evaluated the first element of the queue or not, that is, W1 can't determine if W2 will proceed to the REQUESTED GRANT or to the WAITED stage. Therefore, W1 will signal in both cases. */ class Commit_order_manager { public: Commit_order_manager(uint32 worker_numbers); // Copy logic is not available Commit_order_manager(const Commit_order_manager &) = delete; ~Commit_order_manager(); // Copy logic is not available Commit_order_manager &operator=(const Commit_order_manager &) = delete; /** Initializes the MDL context for a given worker in the commit order queue. @param worker The worker to initialize the context for */ void init_worker_context(Slave_worker &worker); /** Register the worker into commit order queue when coordinator dispatches a transaction to the worker. @param[in] worker The worker which the transaction will be dispatched to. */ void register_trx(Slave_worker *worker); private: /** Determines if the worker passed as a parameter must wait on the MDL graph for other workers to commit and, if it must, will wait for it's turn to commit. @param worker The worker to determine the commit waiting status for. @return false if the worker is ready to commit, true if not. */ bool wait_on_graph(Slave_worker *worker); /** Wait for its turn to commit or unregister. @param[in] worker The worker which is executing the transaction. @retval false All previous transactions succeed, so this transaction can go ahead and commit. @retval true One or more previous transactions rollback, so this transaction should rollback. */ bool wait(Slave_worker *worker); /** Unregister the thread from the commit order queue and signal the next thread to awake. @param[in] worker The worker which is executing the transaction. */ void finish_one(Slave_worker *worker); /** Unregister the transaction from the commit order queue and signal the next one to go ahead. @param[in] worker The worker which is executing the transaction. */ void finish(Slave_worker *worker); /** Reset server_status value of the commit group. @param[in] first_thd The first thread of the commit group that needs server_status to be updated. */ void reset_server_status(THD *first_thd); /** Get rollback status. @retval true Transactions in the queue should rollback. @retval false Transactions in the queue shouldn't rollback. */ bool get_rollback_status(); /** Set rollback status to true. */ void set_rollback_status(); /** Unset rollback status to false. */ void unset_rollback_status(); void report_deadlock(Slave_worker *worker); std::atomic m_rollback_trx; /* It stores order commit order information of all workers. */ cs::apply::Commit_order_queue m_workers; /** Flush record of transactions for all the waiting threads and then awake them from their wait. It also calls gtid_state->update_commit_group() which updates both the THD and the Gtid_state for whole commit group to reflect that the transaction set of transactions has ended. @param[in] worker The worker which is executing the transaction. */ void flush_engine_and_signal_threads(Slave_worker *worker); public: /** Determines if the worker holding the commit order wait ticket `wait_for_commit is in deadlock with the MDL context encapsulated in the visitor parameter. @param wait_for_commit The wait ticket being held by the worker thread. @param gvisitor The MDL graph visitor to check for deadlocks against. @return true if a deadlock has been found and false otherwise. */ bool visit_lock_graph(Commit_order_lock_graph &wait_for_commit, MDL_wait_for_graph_visitor &gvisitor); /** Check if order commit deadlock happens. Worker1(trx1) Worker2(trx2) ============= ============= ... ... Engine acquires lock A ... Engine acquires lock A(waiting for trx1 to release it. COMMIT(waiting for trx2 to commit first). Currently, there are two corner cases can cause the deadlock. - Case 1 CREATE TABLE t1(c1 INT PRIMARY KEY, c2 INT, INDEX(c2)) ENGINE = InnoDB; INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(1, NULL),(2, 2), (3, NULL), (4, 4), (5, NULL), (6, 6) INSERT INTO t1 VALUES(7, NULL); DELETE FROM t1 WHERE c2 <= 3; - Case 2 ANALYZE TABLE t1; INSERT INTO t2 SELECT * FROM mysql.innodb_table_stats Since this is not a real lock deadlock, it could not be handled by engine. slave need to handle it separately. Worker1(trx1) Worker2(trx2) ============= ============= ... ... Engine acquires lock A ... Engine acquires lock A. 1. found trx1 is holding the lock. 2. report the lock wait to server code by calling thd_report_row_lock_wait(). Then this function is called to check if it causes a order commit deadlock. Report the deadlock to worker1. 3. waiting for trx1 to release it. COMMIT(waiting for trx2 to commit first). Found the deadlock flag set by worker2 and then return with ER_LOCK_DEADLOCK. Rollback the transaction Get lock A and go ahead. ... Retry the transaction To conclude, The transaction A which is waiting for transaction B to commit and is holding a lock which is required by transaction B will be rolled back and try again later. @param[in] thd_self The THD object of self session which is acquiring a lock hold by another session. @param[in] thd_wait_for The THD object of a session which is holding a lock being acquired by current session. */ static void check_and_report_deadlock(THD *thd_self, THD *thd_wait_for); /** Wait for its turn to commit or unregister. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. @retval false All previous transactions succeed, so this transaction can go ahead and commit. @retval true The transaction is marked to rollback. */ static bool wait(THD *thd); /** Wait for its turn to unregister and signal the next one to go ahead. In case error happens while processing transaction, notify the following transaction to rollback. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. @param[in] error If true failure in transaction execution */ static void wait_and_finish(THD *thd, bool error); /** Get transaction rollback status. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. @retval true Current transaction should rollback. @retval false Current transaction shouldn't rollback. */ static bool get_rollback_status(THD *thd); /** Unregister the thread from the commit order queue and signal the next thread to awake. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. */ static void finish_one(THD *thd); /** Determines whether current thread needs to wait for its turn to commit and unregister from the commit order queue. The sql commands ALTER TABLE, DROP TABLE, DROP DB, OPTIMIZE TABLE, ANALYZE TABLE and REPAIR TABLE are allowed to wait for its turn to commit and unregister from the commit order queue as exception in MYSQL_BIN_LOG::ordered_commit(), as these transactions have multiple commits and so not determined if the call is ending transaction. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. @retval true Allow thread to wait for it turn @retval false Do not allow thread to wait for it turn */ static bool wait_for_its_turn_before_flush_stage(THD *thd); }; /** MDL subgraph inspector class to be used as a ticket to wait on by worker threads. Each worker will create its own instance of this class and will use its own THD MDL_context to search for deadlocks. */ class Commit_order_lock_graph : public MDL_wait_for_subgraph { public: /** Constructor for the class. @param ctx The worker THD MDL context object. @param mngr The Commit_order_manager instance associated with the current channel's Relay_log_info object. @param worker_id The identifier of the worker targeted by this object. */ Commit_order_lock_graph(MDL_context &ctx, Commit_order_manager &mngr, uint32 worker_id); /** Default destructor. */ virtual ~Commit_order_lock_graph() override = default; /** Retrieves the MDL context object associated with the underlying worker. @return A pointer to the MDL context associated with the underlying worker thread. */ MDL_context *get_ctx() const; /** Retrieves the identifier for the underlying worker thread. @return The identifier for the underlying worker thread. */ uint32 get_worker_id() const; /** Determines if the underlying worker is in deadlock with the MDL context encapsulated in the visitor parameter. @param dvisitor The MDL graph visitor to check for deadlocks against. @return true if a deadlock was found and false otherwise, */ bool accept_visitor(MDL_wait_for_graph_visitor *dvisitor) override; /** Retrieves the deadlock weight to be used to replace a visitor victim's, when more than one deadlock is found. */ uint get_deadlock_weight() const override; private: /** The MDL context object associated with the underlying worker. */ MDL_context &m_ctx; /** The Commit_order_manager instance associated with the underlying worker channel's Relay_log_info object. */ Commit_order_manager &m_mngr; /** The identifier for the underlying worker thread. */ uint32 m_worker_id{0}; }; /** Determines whether current thread shall run the procedure here to check whether it waits for its turn (and when its turn comes unregister from the commit order queue). The sql commands ALTER TABLE, ANALYZE TABLE, DROP DB, DROP EVENT, DROP FUNCTION, DROP PROCEDURE, DROP TRIGGER, DROP TABLE, DROP VIEW, OPTIMIZE TABLE and REPAIR TABLE shall run this procedure here, as an exception, because these transactions have multiple intermediate commits. Therefore cannot predetermine when the last commit is done. @param[in] thd The THD object of current thread. @retval false Commit_order_manager object is not initialized @retval true Commit_order_manager object is initialized */ bool has_commit_order_manager(const THD *thd); #endif /*RPL_REPLICA_COMMIT_ORDER_MANAGER*/